01
Regulation and safety
Each supervising authority will be weighted by the strength of its client-money rules, and the licence checked against the regulator's own register — including whether it covers retail clients where we publish.
02
Total cost of trading
Spreads will be sampled four times a day across a month, then combined with commissions, swaps and non-trading fees into one cost figure per standard lot.
03
Platforms and tools
Each platform will be opened and traded on before it is scored, on charting depth, order types, automation support, uptime, and how much of it costs extra.
04
Deposits and withdrawals
Withdrawal requests will be timed end to end, every fee recorded, and the stated processing window compared with what actually happened.
05
Trader feedback
Feedback will count only once the account behind it is confirmed, and will be grouped by theme so one loud complaint cannot move a score by itself.
06
Support and education
Support queues will be tested anonymously at three times of day, and teaching material graded on whether it is correct, not on how much of it there is.
No broker has been through this process. It is published as a commitment about what a score here would have to mean, not as a description of work already done.